Guest commentary by Ryan Mossman, FuelQuest Fuel Services
Rising and volatile fuel prices are applying significant pressure to commercial fleet operational plans and budgets. In the first two months of the New Year, fuel prices were 50 cents higher than at the same time last year. This was before the unrest in North Africa and the Middle East that continues today, which has driven a barrel of oil above $100 and diesel prices over $4 per gallon.
Many analysts predict that prices will continue to climb and remain highly volatile – reminiscent of 2008. In fact, 2008 provides some key lessons for fleet managers wanting to reign in runaway fuel costs. Companies that weathered 2008, and are consequently prepared for a tough 2011, streamlined their fuel management approach. Streamlining steps they undertook include:
* Benchmark current operations against industry standards
* Strategize optimal supply options
* Contract preferential supply relationships and terms
* Automate, automate, automate
Henry Ford once said, “Before everything else, getting ready is the secret to success.” This is especially true for fleet managers in 2011. Taking these steps provides benefits beyond simply reducing fuel costs and gaining better planning predictability, managers free working capital for other uses within the company and gain a competitive edge in the market with more efficient, cost-effective operations.
Even the best operations can benefit from comparing themselves to established industry best practices and metrics. Most find there are areas in which they can improve, and they gain access to target performance goals that guide operational decisions. In the world of fuel management, it starts with analyses on areas such as:
* Purchase volumes
* Geographic distribution of demand
* Fuel systems infrastructure
* Fuel taxation exemption status by location and use
* Actual invoice line item charges
Based on this analysis, a benchmark study examines the following:
* Best practices
* Published fuel price indices (such as OPIS)
* Time series analysis against published indices
* Ongoing, performance improvement targets
It is difficult to know where to make operational improvements unless you take the time to benchmark against industry best practices. The good news is that there are third-party companies, such as FuelQuest, that provide the people, process, and tools to perform such a benchmark in relatively short order. All a fleet manager has to do is plug into that process.
Before implementing any process improvement steps, it is also important you take a step back and examine the options available in terms of fuel supply including:
* Vendor-managed inventory (VMI)
* Spot or contract delivered sourcing
* Spot or contract FOB sourcing
* Fixed price contracts
Each has advantages and disadvantages depending on the structure of your operations. Also, you can employ some in combination again depending on your operational structure.
When establishing preferential supply contracts, there are important considerations. First, what is your ability and desire to move closer to the rack? In the spectrum of contracting options, the simplest is to cede inventory management to your supplier. Often though, fleet managers lose transparency and pay a premium for this service. Moving up the spectrum, you find delivered spot and delivered contract – each providing more flexibility than the first option, but full transparency and cost savings are not achieved.
The more sophisticated contracting arrangements, and the ones that offer the greatest opportunity to reduce fuel costs, are buying wholesale at the rack or bulk above the rack. These options are clearly for those with sufficient volumes, but, by eliminating the middleman, the opportunity for savings is significant. Of course, as with anything, as the complexity in contracting increases, so does the need for buying expertise and technology – both of which are available through third-party fuel management providers.
When contracting supply for your fleet, it is also important to centralize fuel management operations. It is difficult to implement operational controls when processes and decision-making are distributed. It is also difficult to set up advantaged supply contracts when demand is not aggregated.
Automate, Automate, Automate
Heuristics, manual processes, and spreadsheet-driven fuel management are the anathema of optimized fuel operations. Through automation, fleet managers can gain process control; adopt more sophisticated, advantaged supply arrangements; and drive down fuel costs – typically the highest expense item after headcount. Automation occurs across a number of dimensions:
* Inventory, Order, and Financial Management
* Price Feeds
Such automation enables Just-In-Time (JIT) delivery of fuel, which lowers working capital requirements. Fuel costs are reduced through best practices such as load shifting. Ultimately, fleet managers gain fuel expertise that leads the market.
Will 2011 be a repeat of 2008? The verdict is still out, but what is clear is that fuel prices will continue to be volatile. If “getting ready is the secret to success” as Henry Ford once said, then fleet managers must take the steps necessary to control their operational plans and budgets. This is best accomplished through benchmarking, strategizing, contracting, and automating fuel operations.
Ryan Mossman is vice president and general manager of FuelQuest’s Fuel Services. He leads both of FuelQuest’s outsourced fuel services divisions: Fuel Center and Alarm Management Systems. His FuelQuest experience includes leading large-scale supply chain optimization, technology and business process implementations at large fleet and energy companies including UPS, U.S. Freightway, and Chevron. He can be reached at email@example.com.
The Bottom Line: Related News
5/23/2011 – Getting Ready for More Volatile Fuel Prices with Fuel Purchasing Strategies
Rising and volatile fuel prices are applying significant pressure to commercial fleet operational plans and budgets….
5/20/2011 – Diesel Fuel Prices Are Falling, But Why?
It’s hard to believe that fuel prices are falling, especially if your local gas station has not yet crested the hill at the pump. In fact, most of us have yet to see this. This is because most retail locations are taking their time lowering their prices (and your costs)….
4/8/2011 – Fear and Fleet Fueling Prices
Fleet fueling prices are going up. We see it every day at the pump. We feel it in our wallets. But what exactly is driving diesel and gasoline prices higher?…